A 9-Year-Old Girl Removed from Adoptive Parents & Given to Dad She Never Knew

Legal Services At

Stange Law Firm

  • Family Law
  • Support
  • Military Divorce
  • Child Custody
  • Divorce | Separation
  • Family Violence
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Property Division
  • High Net Worth Divorce

A 9-Year-Old Girl Removed from Adoptive Parents & Given to Dad She Never Knew

A 9-year-old girl was removed from her adoptive parents’ home after her biological father was released from prison and demanded her back.

Since 2006, Sonja had been living with Kim and David Hodgin and was formally adopted by them in 2008. Her father, John McCaul, was serving a 15-year prison sentence on a gun charge that was later reduced to 7-1/2 years, allowing McCaul to assert his parental rights and fight to reverse the adoption.

In November 2009, the court reversed the adoption. The girl continued to live with the Hodgins as both parties fought for custody. Nearly five years later, a judge ruled that Sonya should return to her biological father. Three hours after the ruling, Sonja was gone-to Nebraska from Tennessee.

A day after she was taken from her adoptive parents, she called them and begged to be picked up. She said that her father was nice to her, but his home was full of mold and littered with cigarettes. Despite that, Judge Andy Jackson denied the Hodgins’ request that Sonja be returned to them.

A representative with the Tennessee Department of Children’s Services issued an official statement, which explains why Sonya was placed with her father:

“So many times, foster parents come to love the children who stay in their homes… We see that every day in Tennessee. But we have to remember that the law is clear: Birth parents have the right to raise their children, and that the court system, where the final decision rests, is there to take all sides into account.”

“McCaul has been, as far as we can tell, a good father,” Rob Johnson, Tennessee Department of Children’s Services spokesperson, told the WZTV station, Nashville, TN. “He’s fought for his daughter. Doesn’t have a perfect record – not a boy scout – but he’s done everything the state of Tennessee has asked.”

On Friday, May 16 th, the judge ruled that Sonya will stay with her dad. The Hodgins immediately filed an appeal.

If you are facing a divorce, Stange Law Firm, PC can help. We focus exclusively on family law in the primary areas of divorce, child custody, child support, paternity and other domestic relations issues.

Stange Law Firm, PC offers a half-hour consultation to meet with an attorney. You may call us at 855-805-0595 or visit us online.

Source: New York Daily News, 9-year-old taken from adoptive parents will stay with biological ex-con dad, by Meg Wagner, May 17, 2014


Prenuptial Agreements Line by Line

Aspatore Books from Thomson Reuters Westlaw

Strategies For Family Law Illinois

Aspatore Books from Thomson Reuters Westlaw

Strategies For Military Family Law

Aspatore Books from Thomson Reuters Westlaw

Protect Yourself By Understanding Your Options and Knowing Your Rights


SLF Icon


Stange Law Firm, PC

120 S. Central Avenue, Suite 450

St. Louis (Clayton), Missouri 63105

Toll Free: 855-805-0595
Fax: 314-963-9191
Group 144


Contact Our Team

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Family Law Legal Services At Your Fingertips


When you choose us, you don’t have to sacrifice quality or service. You get the resources of a large divorce and family law firm AND the attentive service of a local attorney.